Prepare for requests that fit the season
Delivery notices, payroll questions, supplier changes, and year-end approvals can give a malicious request a plausible setting. Staff need an easy way to verify the request while continuing legitimate work.
Choose examples that match actual roles and business processes. Explain the independent verification route for sensitive payments or account changes, then test the response to a useful report. Keep campaign comparisons grounded in audience and difficulty rather than assuming a seasonal surge proves a particular risk level.
Put it into practice
Use a harmless shipping notice and a gift-card request in a supervised exercise. Measure how quickly employees report and how the help desk responds. Require independent confirmation for bank-detail changes and urgent payment instructions.

Implementation steps
- Choose a real decisionSelect a payroll change, invoice, document share, or account-recovery request staff actually encounter. Define the safe verification action and provide an accessible reporting route before running an exercise.
- Control the comparisonRecord the audience, delivered messages, lure difficulty, role relevance, and measurement window. Avoid drawing a trend from unrelated campaigns or presenting a small sample as a precise population estimate.
- Test the response systemMeasure whether a useful report reaches the right team and leads to a timely decision. Examine callback procedures, help-desk scripts, mail controls, and payment approvals alongside employee actions.
- Improve without blameUse findings to remove ambiguous steps and make verification easier. Share a practical learning point, protect individual privacy, and repeat a comparable exercise to see whether the process improved.
Track reporting rate and time to useful report
| Measure | Calculation or definition | How to use it |
|---|---|---|
| Reporting rate | Unique useful reporters / delivered exercise messages | Compare only after considering audience and lure difficulty. |
| Time to useful report | First actionable report timestamp minus confirmed delivery timestamp | Include the response team’s acknowledgement and action delay. |
| Verified transaction control | Sensitive changes independently verified / changes sampled | Measure the business control that prevents the loss, not clicks alone. |
Example phishing exercise: distinct outcomes
Worked example. Figures are illustrative.

| Observation | People |
|---|---|
| Delivered | 200 |
| Reported | 60 |
| Clicked | 18 |
Compare campaigns using a consistent audience, delivery denominator, and lure difficulty.
The record to keep
The deliverable: A seasonal phishing exercise log with lure difficulty, reporting timestamps, and a verified payment-change callback procedure.
Before the next busy period, rehearse one supplier or payroll change with the teams that approve it. Fix ambiguous instructions and measure whether the report reaches the person who can act.
References
- NIST TN 2276: Phish Scale User Guide — Interpret exercise results in the context of lure detection difficulty rather than comparing raw click rates alone.
- NIST SP 800-61 Rev. 3: Incident Response — Connect preparation, detection, response, and recovery with the wider risk-management program.
Keep reading.

Winterizing Commercial HVAC Before the First Hard Freeze
Preparing commercial heating equipment for winter requires attention to safe operation, controls, support, and the site's operating needs. The work should follow the equipment manufacturer's requirements and qualified technical judgement.
3 min read →
Technology Sell-Off Pulls U.S. Indexes Lower
Technology and chip shares led Monday’s losses. The Nasdaq fell 2.5%, the S&P 500 logged a third straight decline, and investors looked ahead to retail sales and Nvidia results.
4 min read →
Tech Stocks Weigh on S&P and Nasdaq; Dow Edges Higher
Friday’s close split the major indexes: the Dow rose slightly while technology weakness pulled the S&P 500 and Nasdaq lower. Producer prices cooled monthly but remained elevated year over year.
3 min read →